← Back to all guides
Holiday & Seasonal · 4 min READ

How to Make Buttery Thanksgiving Mashed Potatoes

How to Make Buttery Thanksgiving Mashed Potatoes guide illustration

Choose russets for fluffy mash or Yukon Golds for a denser spoonful. Prep the potatoes the night before and finish with warm milk and butter close to dinner.

Quick note

Follow these steps at your own pace. Check product terms and prices directly with providers before purchasing.

Quick Answer

Start equally sized chunks in cold salted water. Simmer until a knife slides through the largest piece, drain well and let the surface moisture evaporate. Rice or mash while hot, then fold in butter and warm milk just until creamy.

Recipe at a Glance

Plan forDetails
Yield8 side servings
Time20 min prep · 20–30 min on the stove
EquipmentLarge pot, colander and ricer or hand masher

Ingredients

1. Cut and start cold

Peel the potatoes and cut into roughly 1½-inch chunks. Put in a large pot with enough cold water to cover by an inch. Add the cooking salt. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a gentle simmer for 15–20 minutes, checking the largest piece.

2. Let steam escape

Drain thoroughly. Return to the warm pot over low heat for about a minute, shaking gently, until the outside of the potatoes looks dry. Warm the milk separately until steaming.

3. Mash with a light hand

Pass hot chunks through a ricer once or crush with a hand masher. Fold in the butter, then add the warm milk in three additions. Stop when the mash settles softly from the spoon. Taste and add pepper and salt as needed.

4. Finish for the table

Spoon into a warmed serving bowl. Make shallow swirls with the back of a spoon and add a pat of butter or chives. If the mash thickens as you plate, fold in a spoonful of warm milk.

Your Make-Ahead Schedule

WhenWhat to do
Wednesday shortcutPeel and cut the potatoes. Cover completely with cold water and refrigerate overnight. Drain and use fresh cold salted water to cook.
Thursday, for the fluffiest finishSimmer and mash close to serving. While the turkey rests, warm the milk and serving bowl.
If you must finish a day earlyMake the mash, chill promptly in shallow containers, then reheat covered with a splash of milk, stirring occasionally, to 165°F.
Kitchen Tool Buying Tip

A ricer gives a uniform texture without much mixing. Choose a handheld peeler that feels steady when working through several pounds of potatoes.

Common Mistakes and Fixes

What you seeHow to fix it
Mash turns glueyStop beating. A food processor releases too much starch. For the next batch, rice once and fold gently.
Mash tastes thin or wateryDrain and steam-dry before mashing, then add milk gradually. The last splash may be unnecessary.

Before Serving

After Dinner

Divide leftovers into shallow containers and refrigerate within 2 hours, or 1 hour if the surroundings are above 90°F. Keep at 40°F or below and use within 3–4 days. Reheat the portion you need to 165°F.

Bottom Line

If you have only one make-ahead task to spare, peel the potatoes Wednesday and mash them Thursday. You save the messy work and keep the texture people want.

Kitchen References

RECOMMENDED PRODUCTS

A ricer gives a uniform texture without much mixing. Choose a handheld peeler that feels steady when working through several pounds of potatoes.

Prices may change. Check the retailer for the current price and availability. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Learn more.

SHARE THIS GUIDE

Know someone who could use this?

DISCUSSION

Comments

Comments are reviewed before they become public.

No approved comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.