← Back to all guides
Holiday & Seasonal · 4 min READ

How to Make Thanksgiving Baked Mac and Cheese

How to Make Thanksgiving Baked Mac and Cheese guide illustration

Build a smooth cheddar sauce, stop the pasta at the right moment, and get a crisp crumb topping with a short bake.

Quick note

Follow these steps at your own pace. Check product terms and prices directly with providers before purchasing.

Quick Answer

Undercook the elbows slightly, melt freshly grated cheese into the sauce off the heat, and bake only until the edges bubble. For the creamiest holiday pan, grate the cheese and make the crumbs on Wednesday, then cook the pasta on Thursday.

Recipe at a Glance

Plan forDetails
Yield8–10 side servings
Time30 min hands-on · 20–25 min baking · 5–10 min rest
Equipment9 × 13-inch baking pan, large pot and saucepan

Ingredients

1. Start the pasta and the crumbs

Heat the oven to 350°F and grease the baking pan. Cook the elbows in salted water for about 2 minutes less than the package directs. Bite one. There should still be a firm center. Drain. Meanwhile melt 1 tablespoon butter in a skillet, toss with the panko and stir until lightly golden.

2. Whisk a smooth base

Melt the 4 tablespoons butter over medium heat in a saucepan. Whisk in the flour for 1 minute. Add the milk in small pours, whisking smooth after each, then bring it to a gentle simmer. Cook 3–5 minutes, scraping the bottom, until the sauce coats a spoon. Add mustard, salt and pepper.

3. Melt the cheese gently

Take the pan off the burner. Add the grated cheese a handful at a time, stirring until almost melted before the next addition. Taste the sauce and adjust the salt. Fold in the drained pasta. The mixture should look a little looser than you want on the plate because the elbows will absorb some sauce.

4. Give the pan a short bake

Spoon into the pan and spread the buttered crumbs evenly. Bake 20–25 minutes from warm, until the edges bubble, the middle is hot and the topping is golden. Rest 5–10 minutes. A long rest or a long bake will both firm up the center.

Your Make-Ahead Schedule

WhenWhat to do
Wednesday prepGrate both cheeses and refrigerate covered. Toast the crumbs, let cool completely and store airtight separately. Measure flour and mustard.
Thursday finishCook the pasta, make the sauce and assemble while both are warm. Slide the pan into the oven while the turkey rests.
If the whole dish must be made earlyBake the pasta Wednesday without the crumbs. Divide into shallow containers, cool promptly and refrigerate. Transfer back to the pan, add a splash of milk, cover and reheat at 350°F to 165°F in the center. Top with the toasted crumbs at the end.
Kitchen Tool Buying Tip

A box grater turns a block of cheddar into shreds that melt quickly. A shallow baking pan gives more guests some crust and reduces the time the cheese sauce spends in the oven.

Common Mistakes and Fixes

What you seeHow to fix it
The sauce turns grainyRemove it from direct heat before adding cheese. If it starts tightening, stir in a little warm milk and stir gently before adding the pasta.
The next-day pasta is dryLoosen a portion with milk and cover during reheating. Add a fresh spoonful of toasted crumbs at the table.

Before Serving

After Dinner

Divide leftovers into shallow containers and refrigerate within 2 hours, or 1 hour if the surroundings are above 90°F. Keep at 40°F or below and use within 3–4 days. Reheat the portion you need to 165°F.

Bottom Line

For a creamy center and crisp top, finish the stovetop work on Thanksgiving and give the pan just enough oven time to bring it together.

Kitchen References

RECOMMENDED PRODUCTS

A box grater turns a block of cheddar into shreds that melt quickly. A shallow baking pan gives more guests some crust and reduces the time the cheese sauce spends in the oven.

Prices may change. Check the retailer for the current price and availability. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Learn more.

SHARE THIS GUIDE

Know someone who could use this?

DISCUSSION

Comments

Comments are reviewed before they become public.

No approved comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.